Freedom of Speech is Non-Negotiable!


New York Judge Gags Trump-Refuses to Allow Him to Speak

The judge supervising Donald Trump’s civil scams case will not permit the previous president to speak during closing arguments in the trial Thursday after Trump declined to say he would stick to the facts of the case and not take part in any attacks.

Trump had actually asked to deliver part of the arguments himself, said a source with direct knowledge of the circumstance. However New York state Judge Arthur Engoron rejected the demand Wednesday after a controversial back-and-forth with Trump’s legal representatives about specific conditions he desired him to satisfy.

When he rejected the request on Wednesday, Engoron revealed an email conversation in between Trump’s legal representative, Chris Kise, and the office of Letitia James, the Attorney General of New York.

Kise first told Engoron in an e-mail last Thursday that Trump planned to speak, and Andrew Amer of the AG’s workplace rapidly opposed the idea. Allowing Mr. Trump to take part in closing arguments would successfully grant him an opportunity to testify without undergoing cross-examination,” Amer composed.

Engoron responded the next day, stating he was “likely” to let Trump speak due to the fact that he was the individual with “without a doubt the most at stake.” But, he added, Trump needed to discuss the evidence and could not “testify,” “discuss irrelevant matters,” “provide a campaign speech” or “impugn myself, my personnel, plaintiff, plaintiff’s staff or the New York State Court System.

If Trump does not follow those conditions, he will be detached and alerted. If he continues to break those guidelines, the court officers will eliminate him from the courtroom and impose a fine of at least $50,000, as specified by Engoron.

Kise reacted Tuesday that Trump might not consent to those conditions due to the fact that he would be too hamstrung, and he asked Engoron to reconsider. Engoron kept in mind that Trump would be free to comment “on the arguments of an opposing party or counsel, however may not seek to impugn their character.”

“I will not let anybody breach the regular guidelines of courtroom treatment that govern closing arguments,” Engoron included, offering Kise up until 4 p.m. Tuesday to respond.

Kise went beyond the deadline and inquired that closings could perhaps be delayed till completion of January due to the death of Melania Trump’s mother. Engoron responded on Wednesday early morning revealing condolences however declined the ask for a hold-up.

Kise then reacted that Trump was still pertaining to court and prepared to speak. Engoron said Trump could speak just if he accepted his conditions, which Kise replied was “very unreasonable.” “You are not allowing President Trump, who has been wrongfully demeaned and belittled by an out of control, politically motivated Attorney General, to discuss things that must be spoken about,” Kise wrote.

In response, Engoron stated, “Accept it or decline it. This is your final opportunity,” and granted Kise a period of seven minutes to decide based on these conditions. Kise remained quiet, triggering the judge to conclude that Trump would not be giving his testament.

In a statement, Trump’s lawyer Alina Habba said, “Is anybody shocked anymore?”

Throughout the trial, Trump and his legal team consistently revealed displeasure of and had conflicts with Engoron.

The trial lasted more than 2 months, with testament involving December. Trump testified after he was called as a witness by James’ workplace, which sued him last year alleging he and his business had actually fraudulently inflated their assets to get particular rates on bank loans.

During his testament, Trump refuted any claims of misconduct and dealt with frequent reprimands from Engoron for drifting off-topic and averting direct queries. Trump, who has regularly criticized Engoron during project rallies and on different online platforms, identified Engoron as “incredibly antagonistic” while testifying.

Trump was at one point set up to testify in his own defense however announced the night before that he had actually changed his mind. I have currently testified to everything & have absolutely nothing more to state aside from this is a complete & total election disturbance (Biden campaign!) witch hunt,” he stated on his social media platform at the time. “The only scams committed was by the extremely partisan & out of control judge, & racist A.G.,” he added.

Engoron has expressed his intent to release a written judgment within the next few weeks.

Notify of
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x